In 1798, Jenners smallpox vaccine made it possible to prevent the deadliest of childhood diseases. In Denmark the vaccine was used from 1801, and by 1810 a mandatory 1-dose childhood vaccination program was instituted, free of charge. As proof of vaccination (or natural immunity) was required for church confirmation, most children were vaccinated and smallpox disappeared from Copenhagen after 1810 [1]. After a 14-year "honeymoon period", smallpox returned in 1824 with a new face: a milder disease in mostly young adults. Here we investigate the effects of smallpox vaccination on the epidemic patterns throughout the post-honeymoon era (1824-1875). We accessed data from the hospital "Sokvaesthuset" where all smallpox cases, mild and severe, were hospitalized during 1824-1835 in order to contain the outbreak. We identified [~] 3000 smallpox cases in four separate epidemics occurring during this period and accessed data on the age and vaccination status of patients where available. In addition, some information on the number and age distribution of severe smallpox cases and on mortality for outbreaks in the 1860s and 70s is available. We used a mechanistic model (SEIR) to assess factors explaining the return of smallpox, and the changing mean age of cases. We considered vaccination coverage and effectiveness, duration of vaccination-induced immunity, and the fate of the "lost generation" of persons born around 1800, too early to get vaccinated and too late to have been infected with smallpox. Our model tracks well the disappearance and return of smallpox in 1824, its age patterns, and the interval between epidemic peaks. Our study shows that vaccine waning after 25 years on average was likely the primary reason explaining the return of smallpox and the change in its epidemiology in the vaccine era.
Eilersen, A. et al. · CC-BY 4.0